Cambridge coincidences
As of the 23rd May 2022 this website is archived and will receive no further updates.
understandinguncertainty.org was produced by the Winton programme for the public understanding of risk based in the Statistical Laboratory in the University of Cambridge. The aim was to help improve the way that uncertainty and risk are discussed in society, and show how probability and statistics can be both useful and entertaining.
Many of the animations were produced using Flash and will no longer work.
Coincidences have been an intermittently lively topic between two Cambridge
graduates over the years. I remark on them; my wife wonders about the ones
we don't know about. So here are some examples.
I left the army to take up my Cambridge place in 1958, but two years later,
while visiting a friend, he took me to Chipping Camden for the afternoon.
There I encountered one of my former messmates from our regiment in Hong
Kong who was simply making a one-day walking trip to the Cotswolds. A
coincidence, to be sure, but enhanced by a shout from a rooftop where a
third member of that not large mess hailed us as he was fixing an aerial to
his chimney: someone with whom I was no longer in contact and of whose
whereabouts I had been ignorant.
My wife, Hilary and I, with our two young daughters, were sitting at a table
in a crowded cafeteria in the University of Nsukka in 1972. I was there to
give a lecture but the cafeteria was crowded with conference delegates and
we were lucky to grab seats on the last available table. So we were not put
out when an American lady with her young daughter asked if they could occupy
two of the remaining few places. Courteously she began her introductions
with her daughter, who, to our surprise, had the same first and surname as
my wife . It turned out that her husband was a biologist attending the
conference but it is not the sort of coincidence one expects in fairly
remote Nigeria.
Which reminds me of a story told by the Headmistress of a mission school in
Kano. She had just purchased one of the first Toyotas to be imported to
Nigeria and was making the long journey homewards from Lagos. She had left
the rainforest region and was in the less populated Northern savannah when
to her horror her gearstick came away in her hand. Her car came to a
gradual halt and she found herself opposite a 'compound' consisting largely
of a round straw-roofed hut. Before she could gather her wits a smiling
mechanic in Toyota overalls emerged with a tool kit and, having greeted her,
told her he was the only trained Toyota mechanic in Nigeria, who happened to
be visiting his family that week-end. Well, it was a Christian school so I
have to believe her.
And for the unknown one?
This is more complicated. As an adolescent I had a girlfriend who meant a
lot to me and although we drifted apart we both probably felt our
relationship had been significant. Thus it was, that some 50 years on when
she had suffered a marital breakdown in France and sought assistance from an
analyst, she was prevailed to retrace her growing-up and, through the
internet, found my address and sought my side of what she remembered. That
is not relevant but the coincidence lies in the fact that my family and I
spent a sabbatical year in Paris and my 11-year-old son attended a bilingual
school for that year. I turns out that my friend's daughter was in the same
year at the same school but in the French rather than the bilingual class.
We did not discover this. We did not meet, despite living close by. So we
did not realise the coincidence at the time and would never have done so in
the normal course of events.
As my wife points out - it is remarkable if three acquaintances find
themselves, by coincidence, together in a railway carriage; but is it not
also a coincidence if they happen to be in three adjacent railway carriages
and do not discover each other?
Date submitted:Fri, 20 Jan 2012 17:36:44 +0000Coincidence ID:5617