Mobile phones and behavioural problems

This article found an association between mobile phone use in pregnancy and behavioural problems in childhood, with an additional association with the child using a mobile phone before they were 7. I was not the only one reported as being sceptical, but the study is predictably getting a lot of coverage particularly in pregnancy advisory websites.

The authors did their best with a large survey, but they admit that mobile phone use in pregnancy is associated with being poorer, younger, more stressed, smoking, and doubtless many other factors that are known to increase the risk of behavioural problems. It is difficult to tease out the effect of a single factor even using statistical adjustment methods. They also find an association between mobile phone use in children under 7, even without use by their mothers were pregnant, and behavioural problems. Such an association is unsurprising, but I am not convinced that it's the phone use that causes the problems.

Levels: 

Comments

Anonymous's picture

Is there some way to calculate how many "Scientific Studies" in human health are in fact non-sequiturs because the sample group is inadequatly representive of the general population or has false cause-effect conclusions reported? I think it is <75% Furthermore, the cynic in me thinks those reported in newspapers are more likely to be deliberately misleading to support a particular viewpoint. I think the probability of this is <95%
truxton's picture

Is there some way to calculate how many "Scientific Studies" in human health are in fact non-sequiturs because the sample group is inadequatly representive of the general population or has false cause-effect conclusions reported? I think it is <75% Furthermore, the cynic in me thinks those reported in newspapers are more likely to be deliberately misleading to support a particular viewpoint. I think the probability of this is <95%
truxton's picture

Fascinating check this site out www.lowermycellphoneplan.com/solavei/

You can lower cell phone bill or get it for completely free.. It's definitely worth checking out seriously available nationwide... Just thought you guys would want to know about it.